Workshop 06
Individual Memo

EPA PCE 2024

Rony Rodrigo Maximiliano Rodriguez-Ramirez

Harvard University

November 25, 2024

Workshop Objectives

  • Understand the structure and purpose of an Individual Memo.
  • Analyze and critique sample memos from a client’s perspective.
  • Learn strategies for crafting concise, impactful memos tailored to policymaker needs.
  • Discuss responsible use of AI tools in memo writing.
  • Practice framing a memo as a story: problem, options, recommendation, and evidence.

Key Elements of a Policy Memo

  • Purpose: Provide clear, actionable recommendations for your client.
  • Components:
    • Recommendation: What should the client do?
    • Analysis: Why is this the best option?
    • Evidence: Support your claims with relevant data.
    • Clarity: Write so your client can use your memo to convince others.
  • Length: 400–600 words (excluding tables, figures, and references).

First Activity: Memo Critique (20 minutes)

Out of the 4 memos listed on Canvas:

  • Pick one between Example 3 and 4.
  • In the first 5-10 minutes, read the memo.
  • Remaining minutes discuss the questions in the following slide with the whole group.

You will judge which memo is the “strong”/“weak” one

Option 1: Analyze a Strong Memo

  • Review a 2022 memo sample (700–800 words).
  • Imagine you are the client listed as the recipient.
  • Questions:
    • What do you like about this memo?
    • What makes the recommendation clear and convincing?
    • How does it balance brevity with depth?

Option 2: Improve a Weak Memo

  • Review a less effective memo.
  • Identify weaknesses:
    • Is the recommendation clear?
    • Are the arguments focused and evidence-based?
    • Does it meet the client’s needs?
  • Propose revisions to improve clarity and impact.

Memo as a Story: Problem-Solving Framework (10 minutes)

From the examples you just read:

  • Problem: What issue needs solving?
  • Options: What alternatives are available?
  • Recommendation: What is the best course of action?
  • Evidence: Why is this recommendation effective?

Discuss the consequences of:

  1. Action: What will improve or change if the recommendation is adopted?
  2. Inaction: What happens if the client does nothing?

Writing Strategies: Eric Taylor’s Guide

  • Know Your Audience:
    • Understand their needs, prior beliefs, and decision-making scope. Tailor your recommendations to align with their priorities.
  • Write Simply:
    • Use clear, concise language; avoid jargon unless necessary. Active voice and first-person perspective make writing more direct.
  • Organize Strategically:
    • Place the bottom line at the top—state your recommendation and main argument upfront. Integrate relevant background information into the narrative.
    • Use meaningful section titles to convey your argument clearly.
  • Practice Brevity:
    • Include only the most essential ideas and arguments.

Writing Strategies: Eric Taylor’s Guide

  • Use Visual Aids Effectively:
    • Include graphs, diagrams, and tables to simplify complex data.
  • Reason, Then Communicate:
    • Every claim must have supporting evidence and reasoning. Anticipate and address the best counterarguments to your recommendation.
  • Check for Robustness:
    • Explicitly state assumptions and test whether changes to those assumptions affect your recommendation.
  • Final Tip:
    • Tie every point back to what your client cares about most—whether it’s cost-efficiency, political feasibility, or another priority.

AI in Memo Writing

  • HGSE AI Policy: Guidelines for ethical and responsible AI use.
  • Check it here!
  • How can AI enhance your work while maintaining originality and analytical rigor?
    • Shall we use AI?

Final Exercise: Elevator Pitch using your PAP

  • Activity:
    • Write a 1-minute pitch summarizing your memo.
    • Pair up and exchange feedback.
  • Tips:
    • Start with the recommendation.
    • Explain the problem and why your solution is best.
    • Tie back to client priorities (e.g., cost, political feasibility).
    • Peter Wilcoxen Tip’s are excellent, you should use them!! Link

Takeaways

  • A well-written memo is concise, focused, and actionable.
  • Tailor the content to the client’s priorities and context.
  • Approach the memo as a story:
    • problem, options, recommendation, and evidence.

Final Note: It was great meeting you all. I’m always around. Don’t hesitate to contact me, anytime :)